Katalon records your clicks. Pie finds the flows.

Get the flows found and the tests written for you. Pie’s agents explore your apps, where Katalon gives your testers an IDE to record and script each test.

Pie

Pie is an agentic testing platform whose agents find the flows in your web, iOS and Android apps, write the tests and run them, with nothing for your testers to record.

Katalon

Katalon is a low-code test automation suite built around a desktop IDE. Your testers record tests, build them from keywords or script them in Groovy or Java.

The basics

Pie vs Katalon at a glance

PieAgentic testing platform
What it is
An agentic testing platform for web, iOS and Android apps.
What you bring
Your app, as a URL, an iOS simulator build or an Android APK. No scripts.
Where tests run
Web apps in a browser. iPhone, iPad and Android phones and tablets on simulators and emulators, on the OS version you pick.
AI help
The whole product. Agents explore your app, write and run the tests, group what they find into issues, and can open a Fix PR for your team to review.
How it’s priced
Custom pricing, tailored to your team’s requirements and testing volume. Contact Pie for a quote.
KatalonLow-code test automation suite
What it is
A desktop IDE for recording, building and scripting tests.
What you bring
Your testers’ time. They record tests, build them from keywords or script them in Groovy or Java.
Where tests run
On your machine, in CI or on Katalon’s cloud.
AI help
On paid plans, AI agents for low-code authoring, failure analysis and locator repair. TrueTest generates tests from production sessions.
How it’s priced
A free plan for local use. Professional is $1,800 per seat per year.
Who does what

Five jobs in every test. Which product does each one?

A working test has to be written, run in CI, run somewhere your users are, tracked and repaired. Here is which Katalon product handles each part, and how Pie handles it.

The jobKatalonPie
Write the test

KatalonKatalon Studio. Your testers record, use keywords or script it. $1,800 per seat per year on Professional.

PiePie writes it. Tell Pie Chat what to check, and it explores the flow and drafts the test for your OK.

Run it in CI

KatalonRuntime Engine, an add-on. Each license covers one active execution session at a time.

PiePie runs it. Suites run on a schedule or on every new build, with nobody starting them.

Run it in the cloud

KatalonTestCloud, an add-on, with desktop browsers and real iOS and Android devices.

PieTests run in Pie, on simulators, emulators and a browser. Nothing to host.

Track the results

KatalonTestOps, at $80 per seat per month when bought on its own.

PiePie groups related findings into issues. Your team decides what counts as a bug.

Repair it after a UI change

Katalon“Katalon AI fixes the test and you review it.” Not on the free plan.

PieNo locators to repair. Pie re-reads the screen on every run.

Where they differ

Four reasons to stop recording tests by hand.

  1. 01

    A seat buys the IDE

    Professional is $1,800 per seat per year, and your team still builds the suite. Pie’s agents write and run it.

    Source
  2. 02

    A recorder needs someone clicking

    Katalon’s recorders capture the clicks your testers make. TrueTest can generate tests, from production user sessions you send it. Pie’s agents explore your running app, so you get tests for flows nobody has recorded.

    Source
  3. 03

    No locators to heal or approve

    When a locator breaks, Katalon tries others it stored, then has an AI model propose one, and reports the fix for your approval. Pie’s tests have no locators for your team to write, heal or approve.

    Source
  4. 04

    Explore, write, run and report in one place

    Pie explores, writes, runs and reports in one place, across web, iOS and Android, with API and accessibility testing in beta.

Side by side

An IDE for your testers, or agents that do the work.

Katalon hands your testers an IDE. Pie’s agents hand them results.

What you’re comparingPieKatalonAdvantage
Cost to run it No scripts to write and no locators to break, so your team spends those hours on your product. Seats, and your testers’ hours to build and maintain the suite. Pie
Writing the tests Agents generate them by exploring your app. Your testers record them, build them from keywords or script them in Groovy or Java, with AI agents on paid plans. Pie
Starting with no suite Pie explores your app and generates tests, with no suite to build first. You record or script tests first. TrueTest can generate them from production sessions you send it. Pie
When the UI changes No locators to repair. Pie re-reads the screen on every run. On paid plans, Katalon proposes a new locator and reports the fix for your review. Pie
Fixing the bug Pie can open a Fix PR with a proposed fix in a repo you connect. Merging it is always your team’s call. AI failure analysis sorts a failure into a real bug, an environment issue or a test problem. The fix is your team’s. Pie
Desktop apps Pie tests web, iOS and Android apps. Native Windows desktop apps, as well as web and mobile. Katalon
Real devices and browsers Real devices are available on demand. Simulators and emulators cover iPhone, iPad and Android. TestCloud has real iPhones, iPads and Android phones, and four desktop browsers on Windows and macOS. Both
The exception

When the product is a Windows desktop app

You test Windows desktop apps

Katalon Studio tests native Windows desktop apps as well as web and mobile. Pie tests web, iOS and Android apps.

Source
Who should pick which

Which fits your team, Pie or Katalon?

Pick Pie to

  • Test more of your app without recording another test.
  • Get results across web, iOS and Android with no suite to build first.
  • Give your team back the hours it spends building and reviewing tests.
  • Check your pull requests the way your users will use them.
  • Run UI, API and accessibility testing from one product.

Pick Katalon if

  • You test native Windows desktop apps.
Getting started

Switch from Katalon one flow at a time

No big rewrite. Your Katalon tests keep running until Pie covers the same flow.

  1. 1

    Add your app

    Use a URL for your web app, or an iOS simulator build or an Android APK for mobile. If it has a login, add a test login through a supported path.

  2. 2

    Let Pie explore

    Pie explores your app’s reachable flows and generates tests. You get results in hours, not weeks.

  3. 3

    Add your edge cases

    Type the cases only your team knows into Pie Chat in plain English. Pie explores each flow, drafts the test and runs it once you confirm.

  4. 4

    Retire tests as Pie covers them

    Compare Pie’s results with your Katalon runs, and retire each test once Pie covers the flow.

FAQ

Did we miss a question?
Email us directly →

Is Pie a Katalon alternative?

Yes. Pie replaces the tests your team records and scripts with tests its agents generate by exploring your app.

Stay on Katalon if you test Windows desktop apps.

How much does Katalon cost?

Katalon has a free plan for local use, and Professional is $1,800 per seat per year, billed annually.

Your team still builds and reviews the suite. Half the organizations in the World Quality Report 2025-26 name maintenance burden and flaky scripts as a test automation challenge.

Pie’s pricing is custom, tailored to your team’s requirements and testing volume. Contact Pie for a quote.

Is Katalon free?
Katalon has a free plan for authoring tests and running them on your own machine. Your testers still record or script each test.
Doesn’t Katalon have AI now?

Yes. On paid plans, Katalon has AI agents for low-code authoring, failure analysis and locator repair, and TrueTest generates tests from production user sessions you send it.

Its own line is “Katalon AI fixes the test and you review it.” Pie’s agents explore your app without waiting for user sessions, and its tests have no locators to repair.

Can Pie test mobile apps?
Yes. Pie tests native iOS apps on the iOS Simulator and Android apps on the Android Emulator, along with web apps. Real devices are available on demand.
Does Pie test APIs and accessibility too?

Yes, and both are in beta. Pie runs whole API flows call by call, and checks each screen its tests reach for accessibility problems.

Your UI, API and accessibility testing sit in one place.

What do Katalon users complain about?

Speed and upkeep come up most. Reviewers on G2 and PeerSpot say Katalon slows down on large test suites and is heavy on a laptop, and that test cases get hard to maintain when the app’s UI changes.

Pie runs the tests on its own machines, and they have no locators for your team to maintain.

How do I move from Katalon to Pie?
One flow at a time. Add your app, let Pie generate tests, and type your edge cases into Pie Chat. Keep your Katalon tests running until Pie covers the same flow, then retire them.
Who on my team runs Pie?

Whoever owns quality today, such as a QA lead or an engineer who owns releases. Pie does the exploring, writing and re-running, and the owner decides what matters and what counts as a bug.

Anyone on the team, including a product manager, can read a test or add one in plain English.

Stop recording tests one click at a time.

Book a demo and tell us which flows your testers record today. We’ll show you the tests Pie’s agents find on their own.

Sources

  1. Katalon pricing. Free plan with local authoring, record and playback and local execution; no parallel, cloud or CI/CD headless execution, desktop testing or self-healing on Free. Professional is $1,800 per seat per year billed annually, with AI agents for low-code authoring, failure analysis and self-healing. CI/CD headless execution requires a Runtime Engine add-on and cloud execution requires TestCloud add-ons.katalon.com/pricing
  2. Katalon TestCloud. Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Edge on Windows and macOS; real iOS and Android devices.katalon.com/testcloud
  3. Katalon Studio. Record and replay, built-in keywords, or Groovy and Java scripts; web, iOS and Android, REST, SOAP and GraphQL APIs, and native Windows desktop apps.katalon.com/studio
  4. Katalon TrueTest. Generates tests from real user sessions in production; you forward production telemetry. Release notes say generating tests from user sessions must be enabled by the TrueTest team.katalon.com/truetest
  5. Self-healing tests in Katalon Studio, and the Katalon home page. Tries other stored locators first, then an AI fallback proposes a locator and the suggested fix is reported for approval. “Katalon AI fixes the test and you review it.”docs.katalon.com/katalon-studio/maintain-tests/self-healing-tests-in-katalon-studio
  6. World Quality Report 2025-26 (Capgemini, Sogeti, OpenText), Fig 15. 50% cite maintenance burden and flaky scripts as a test automation challenge.capgemini.com/insights/research-library/world-quality-report-2025-26
  7. PeerSpot, Katalon Studio room for improvement. Reviewers cite slow execution and memory use.peerspot.com/products/katalon-studio-room-for-improvement
  8. G2, Katalon reviews. Reviewers cite slow execution with large test suites, heavy hardware use and test maintenance when UI elements change.g2.com/products/katalon/reviews